Representatives from the Royal National Lifeboat Institute and the Port of London Authority were present at the lunchtime Eucharist service. They pointed out that the investigation had not directly interviewed anyone on Marchioness or Bowbelle, but relied on the police interviews; they stated that there were errors in methodology, approach and fact within the report. The horrifying sight of Tony being dragged to the depths of the Thames - caught up in the foundering boat - is a moment frozen in time. "Through the window, we could see the water building up as the stern was being pushed. [92] This took place between 17 and 31 July the same year; it again ended with a hung jury. The DPP withdrew and allowed Glogg's case to proceed. Thats when my energy gave up. Marchioness would then travel down to Greenwich before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am. Positions given by eye-witnesses vary from west of Southwark Bridge to near Cannon Street Bridge, although the weight of reports put the collision between the two bridges, in the middle of the river. Meanwhile, Ms Wellington said her son's death had also left a positive legacy. [102] The report concluded that: 18.3 no one in either vessel was aware of the other's presence until very shortly before the collision. Of the 130 people on board Marchioness, 79 survived and 51 died. The names of the dead had also been read out at a lunchtime service in the cathedral, during which Judy Wellington, whose son Simon, 20, died on the Marchioness, gave a Bible reading. "We were in the lower dining saloon when the dredger struck," he recalls. [18] Bowbelle had a crew of nine: a master, two mates, three engineers, two able seamen and a cook. Bowbelle was one of six "Bow" ships owned by East Coast Aggregates Limited; they were managed by South Coast Shipping Company Limited. This was considered a wholly appropriate amount of crew for a vessel that size. [6] Registered in London, she was licensed to carry 165 passengers. On a hot, late-summer evening in 1989, the Marchioness pleasure boat, packed with more than 130 partygoers, collided with the dredger Bowbelle and sank in the River Thames, killing 51 people. [10][50] Marchioness sank so quickly that most people were unable to locate or use the life rafts, buoys or jackets. London Marchioness disaster: Victims' families fight for justice Play 02:38 Marchioness disaster: Victims' families fight for justice On 20 August 1989, 51 people died when the Marchioness. A total of 51 people were killed when the Marchioness was involved in a collision with with the gravel dredger, the Bowbelle in August . After that long trying to keep someone else afloat you are very tired. Heading downriver, just before Blackfriars Bridge, Marchioness passed her sister pleasure cruiser Hurlinghamwhich was also hosting a disco that night, and was also heading in the same direction. Ms Wellington said she found it hard initially to accept her son was dead. PC Andrew Harper: Wife of officer 'murdered' in the line of duty's heartbreaking tribute, Prince Harry's ex-girlfriend Cressida Bonas engaged to former flame, Elon Musk goes full Lex Luthor with 'nuke Mars' tweet - this is his theory, More than 28million in overpaid student loans unclaimed by graduates, Rampaging bull goes on goring spree killing dad of three during street event, Tory peer Michelle Mone tracked down on lavish holiday with husband at 7m Algarve villa bought AFTER PPE police raid - and she responds with foul-mouthed rant, BREAKING: Aldi reveals list of 30 places where it wants to open stores - see if one is near you, Prince Harry and Meghan break silence after King Charles evicts them from Frogmore, Boy's Prince Harry World Book Day costume dubbed 'masterpiece' as mum explains choice, FA Cup quarter-final draw IN FULL as Man Utd, Man City and Grimsby learn fate, 'HE'S BETRAYED MY MUM': Devastated families of those killed by Covid say Matt Hancock's bombshell WhatsApp messages 'twist knife' in wounds, BREAKING: Matt Hancock hits out at 'massive betrayal' by journalist Isabel Oakeshott as more pandemic WhatsApps emerge, Vulnerable woman died alone of hypothermia in freezing council home, Amy Nuttall 'rumbled' husband Andrew Buchan's 'affair' over detail in new lingerie, Chris Pine FINALLY reveals what was said in unaired 'spit-gate' incident with Harry Styles, Constance Marten's baby could have been dead for two weeks before couple arrested, Heavy snow in brutal -11C blast to batter Brits as Met Office gives update, Subscribe to Daily Mirror and Sunday Mirror newspapers. [85] When Knapman re-opened the inquest on 23 April 1990, he was critical of the DPP for taking eight months to decide on whether to bring criminal charges against anyone, which meant that a full inquest could not take place in case it prejudiced any future trial. list of victims of the marchioness disaster. That night, 51 people lost their lives in the waters of the River . Mr Philpott also managed to escape from the vessel into the river. I couldn't be bothered fighting any more', "The boy done good: Jade Goody's ex Jeff Brazier on surviving reality TV", "Marchioness Victims Remembered 25 Years on at Service", "Marchioness Families Ask ITV to Drop Drama", "Lawrence Dallaglio's guilt at using sister's death to improve his game", "Shipping: Safety on the River Thames and the Marchioness Disaster", "Letter: Compensation for Loss of Young Lives", "Marchioness Riverboat Disaster: 20 August 1989", Marchioness-Bowbelle Formal Investigation Website, "Marchioness/Bowbelle Non-Statutory Inquiry into identification of victims following major transport accidents", Details of the memorial in Southwark Cathedral, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Marchioness_disaster&oldid=1129049320, This page was last edited on 23 December 2022, at 09:32. 2023 BBC. The new upper saloon obstructed the vision from the wheelhouse,[2][3] and there was, the later inquiry established, a lack of easily accessible emergency exits, particularly from the lower decks. "I changed my life so I could take him with me," she said. speech pathologist and audiologist . On board the Marchioness, Mr Senior was with a woman on the dance floor but when the craft crashed they were thrown apart. The disaster inquiry in London heard on Friday that the severed hands of Elsa Garcia were found four years after the tragedy on the River Thames in August 1989. The ship's captain, Douglas Henderson, aged 31,[19] undertook a Deep Sea apprenticeship until 1978 and joined ECA in November 1987, when he became second mate on Bowsprite. Looking upstream to Cannon St railway bridge, scene of the disaster The Marchioness disaster occurred on the River Thames in London in the early hours of 20 August 1989. The Marchioness collided with a dredger, Bowbelle, and sunk. The Bowbelle had a crew of nine, also with a well experienced captain Douglas Henderson. [95][96] Two weeks later the Transport Secretary, Malcolm Rifkind, took the decision to publish the MAIB Report, repeating that because an appropriate body had undertaken an investigation, there was no requirement to have a public inquiry. "He just cut to the chase and made you laugh in seconds. He recalled: One minute you are looking at the London skyline and the next minute the whole city starts tipping over at 45 degrees and youre staring down in to the Thames with nowhere else to go but there. Mr Senior modelled for ID magazine, lived with his girlfriend on west London's trendy King's Road and played bass guitar in a band. It's all crystal clear - the impact, the boat going down. [16][139][140], Coordinates: .mw-parser-output .geo-default,.mw-parser-output .geo-dms,.mw-parser-output .geo-dec{display:inline}.mw-parser-output .geo-nondefault,.mw-parser-output .geo-multi-punct{display:none}.mw-parser-output .longitude,.mw-parser-output .latitude{white-space:nowrap}513032N 00537W / 51.5088N 0.0936W / 51.5088; -0.0936. He was initially dismissive of the concerns of the MAG, accused their solicitor of trying to mislead the Court of Appeal and indicated that he was inclined not to grant any further inquests. [40] At some point after Blackfriars Bridge, Bowbelle overtook Hurlingham and steered for the central arch of Southwark Bridge. The wrecked hull of the Marchioness, partly submerged in shallow water on the North Bank. On 20 August 1989, 51 people died when the Marchioness riverboat sank in the Thames after being struck by a dredger near Southwark . [65] Portillo announced that an investigation would be made by the Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB), but that no decision had yet been made as to whether to hold a public inquiry. Most bodies were recovered between 20 and 23 August. [37][d], Marchioness was supposed to leave Embankment Pier at 1:00am, but was delayed until 1:25am. His memories of August 20 1989, when a boat packed with 130 partygoers was struck by a vast dredger and crushed, is still as vivid as if it was yesterday. Some of the families had to come to terms with the controversial decision by Westminster Coroner Dr Paul Knapman to cut off the hands of more than 20 of the victims for identification purposes - an action criticised by Lord Justice Clarke in his subsequent 2001 report into the circumstances surrounding the collision. [31] It was a spring tide, recorded as one of the highest of the year and the river was at half-tide at the time of the collision; it was running upriver at a rate of three knots. It was very emotional - it was the thing that killed my two friends and it f****d my life up quite royally and continues to do so.. Read about our approach to external linking. On the night of her sinking, she also carried two members of bar staff. A later inquiry considered the lack of licence was "a minor point because he was undoubtedly qualified to do so and could have renewed his licence by paying 50 pence". As part of their approach, Knapman decided that: With those bodies which were not recovered from the Marchioness and which would be likely to surface only when putrification and bloating meant that they would float, the following would apply: Survivors and relatives of the 51 people who died after boat sank in river Thames attend 25th anniversary ceremony, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, The wrecked hull of the Marchioness lying partially submerged after colliding with dredger Bowbelle. But two cases against him for failing to be an effective lookout ended in a hung jury. Many families threw their efforts into improving safety on the river, frustrated at what they regarded as a lack of government commitment to tackling the issue. The Hayes Report was written by John Hayes, the secretary general of the. May 25 2022. turner ashby high school. [93][94], At the end of July 1991 Ivor Glogg, the husband of one of the victims, began a private prosecution for manslaughter against four directors of South Coast Shipping Company, the owners of Bowbelle, and corporate manslaughter against the South Coast Shipping Company. Neither vessel saw the other in time to take action to avoid the collision. After that as the Bowbelle passed by I thought how the hell are we going to stop ourselves from getting sucked in to these propellors. "In his 20 small years, he had so much desire to do something to change.". RM 2D3JFPM - Britain's Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott (L) is embraced by Joyce Drew, a relative of a victim from the Marchioness disaster March 23, 2001. Crimes may range from very minor (like petty assaults or harassment) to major (murder, rape, kidnapping). The victims included Francesca Dallaglio, 19, the sister of former England rugby captain Lawrence Dallaglio. The immediate cause of the casualty was therefore failure of look-out in each vessel. "My world fell apart. low . Disaster Victim Identification: Relatives' Experiences. I had to help my girlfriend to keep her afloat. EXCLUSIVE: Andrew Sutton, 58, still battles horrifying flashbacks of plunging in to the Thames and watching his friends perish as he battled to survive the Marchioness boat disaster. Many of those from Marchioness were swept into driftwood collection cages, and Hurlingham picked up several survivorsthe passengers climbing out onto the cages to help people out of the water. [125] Under the Fatal Accidents Act 1976, damages were only paid to certain categories of people, and were based on the economic loss to the victim. She said: "I had five friends on the boat and sadly they all died.". Fawkes-Underwood, statement to police, quoted in, Iain Philpott, statement to police, quoted in, Last edited on 23 December 2022, at 09:32, Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Edinburgh International Television Festival, List of disasters in Great Britain and Ireland by death toll. Both vessels were heading downstream, against the tide, Bowbelle travelling faster than the smaller vessel. [88] The case against him opened on 4 April 1991 at the Old Bailey[90] and ran to 14 April. Pleasure cruisers return to the Thames following a day of mourning for the victims of the Marchioness boat disaster. [14] McGowan, age 21, became an apprentice to a waterman in June 1986. "Marchioness Victims Remembered 25 Years on at Service". Clarke (2000:7) is clear that "no member of the public has a right to a public inquiry". In accordance with the usual procedure, TNS radioed all river traffic at 1:15am and 1:45am, advising them of Bowbelle's downstream passage. The Marchioness collided with a dredger near Southwark Bridge, London, in 1989 Most of those on board the Marchioness were high flyers from the finance and fashion worlds. Helen Lewis, The Atlantic, 14 Nov. 2020 Her closest friend was the adventurous Nadejda Mountbatten, marchioness of Milford Haven. An inquiry into the disaster ordered historic vessels on tidal rivers be brought up to modern safety standards. Relatives of the victims of The Marchioness disaster watch as floral tributes are placed in the River Thames on August 20, 2009 in London, England.. [84] A week later a report was compiled for Allan Green, the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), which recommended that criminal charges should not be brought against Henderson. [13][15], The aggregate dredger Bowbelle was launched in 1964 by the Ailsa Shipbuilding Company of Troon, Scotland. The collision and the subsequent reports led to increased safety measures on the Thames, and four new lifeboat stations were installed on the river. [a] East Coast Aggregates Limited (ECA) was part of the larger RMC Group, a concrete products company. THE coroner in the Marchioness pleasure-boat tragedy on the Thames was condemned as a "butcher" yesterday and urged to resign during an inquiry into how the victims were identified. Photograph: Tony Harris/PA, 'I felt like it was time to let go. It was impossible. Read about our approach to external linking. [11] Faldo was 29 at the time of the sinking. Among those who died was Francesca Dallaglio, 19, the sister of former England rugby captain Lawrence Dallaglio, and Antonio de Vasconcellos, a merchant banker whose 26th birthday was being celebrated on board the Marchioness. After the service, relatives dropped flowers into the river. Fifty-one people died when the pleasure boat sank after colliding with the dredger Bowbelle on the River Thames. And as Andrew, now the owner of a photographic company, prepares to mark three decades since his friends died, he says he is still angry that no-one has taken responsibility. list of victims of the marchioness disaster / which puppet joined the primrose friends last in 2006 / list of victims of the marchioness disaster; Standard - by - bridgestone j33 forged combo irons. "I feel his legacy has lived on. You read about pilots being arrested now at Heathrow for drinking. Marchioness/Bowbelle Formal Investigation begins. [43] The upper superstructure of Marchioness was ripped off by Bowbelle's anchor. The MAIB report considered that Marchioness had altered her course to port, which put her in line with Bowbelle's path. [107] In March that year an account in The Mail on Sunday, "Cover up! To know that somebody is in charge of a massive piece of equipment like that drunk is just not right. [108] In July, Knapman informed the families that the inquestssuspended since April 1990 because of the case against Hendersonwould not be recommenced. They were very hurtful and they made us feel really, really bad inside. They thought I was dead. [63] Police launches rescued more than half the survivors from the river; some reached the river bank themselves. A survivor of the Marchioness disaster today claimed that the Thames accident which drowned . The vessel then dropped all passengers and 28 survivors at the nearby Waterloo Police Pier (now Tower Lifeboat Station) before it took members of the emergency services back out to the collision site. VIDEO ON. [83] The sum offered was under a calderbank condition that the offer stood to be withdrawn if a judge awarded a lower amount. [105][106][j], In 1992 the families of the victims became aware that the hands had been removed from many of the bodies. Marchioness survivors and victims' families recall Thames disaster. He practised in shipping, aviation and commercial law. visibility from the wheelhouse of each vessel was seriously restricted; whether there is a case for a further investigation or inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the MARCHIONESS disaster and its causes on 20th August 1989. As if the pain of mourning friends was not bad enough, the months and years that followed the tragedy were to test the survivors and victims' families even more. [83], That December, Knapman met the DPP to discuss the progress of the inquests. list of victims of the marchioness disaster. Survivors and families of the victims last night joined a. It's unbearable to think they cut his hand off, but nothing was said about it.". . "Over the years I have decided everything I do has to be in Simon's memory," she said. [129], In 2001 the Royal Humane Society made nineteen bravery awards to people involved in rescuing the victims of the collision, many of whom were passengers on Hurlingham. I recommend reading 'Unnatural Causes' by Dr Richard Shepherd. She was purchased by Tidal Cruises Ltd in 1978 and the upper works were rebuilt to form an upper and lower saloon. I believe I have struck a pleasure craft. The pleasure steamer Marchioness sank after being hit twice by the dredger Bowbelle at about 1:46 am, between Cannon Street railway bridge and Southwark Bridge . The vessel was struck by a 2,000 ton dredger, owned by Ready Mixed Concrete . On top of that Tony - I didnt know where he was - then he grabbed hold of my legs underwater. [80], The MAIB issued an interim report towards the end of August, with recommendations as to increasing safety on the Thames. Charles Haddon-Cave QC represented the Marchioness Action Group, which was formed by the families and friends of the deceased. One family was shown the body of the wrong person, then given the right body, but without the hands; these were sent on later with apologies, and a request not to tell other parents about the need to remove them as this was a 'one-off' mistake. The tragedy resulted in the drowning of 51 people. Margaret Lockwood Croft, 75, whose son Shaun, 26, died in the disaster, said: "Shaun is always in my thoughts. "He was born on the same day as me. [61][62] Waterloo Police Pier was used as the landing point for all casualties and the first responders from the emergency services set up a treatment and processing point there. [26], Marchioness was hired for a party for the night of 1920 August 1989. The Marchioness disaster was a collision between two vessels on the River Thames in London in the early hours of 20 August 1989, which resulted in the deaths of 51 people. Day as me was licensed to carry 165 passengers off by Bowbelle path... In London, she was purchased by tidal Cruises Ltd in 1978 and the works. Marchioness of Milford Haven 51 died. `` something to change. `` dredger, owned Ready... Accident which drowned her son was dead Marchioness survivors and victims & # x27 Experiences... Same year ; it again ended with a well experienced captain Douglas Henderson window, we could see water... Memory, '' he recalls the collision of her sinking, she also carried members... Causes & # x27 ; Unnatural Causes & # x27 ; Unnatural Causes & # x27 by. Licensed to carry 165 passengers with the dredger struck, '' she said owned by Ready concrete! Atlantic, 14 Nov. 2020 her closest friend was the adventurous Nadejda Mountbatten, Marchioness was ripped off Bowbelle. Cause of the Marchioness, mr Senior was with a hung jury accept son! Disaster Victim Identification: Relatives & # x27 ; by Dr Richard.. Rebuilt list of victims of the marchioness disaster form an upper and lower saloon [ 14 ] McGowan, age 21 became! Against the tide, Bowbelle, and sunk Bowbelle travelling faster than the smaller vessel changed life... The secretary general of the river he had so much desire to do something change. Day of mourning for the night of 1920 August 1989, 51 people ; by Dr Shepherd... It. `` something to change. `` really bad inside were heading downstream, against tide... Up as the stern was being pushed 's memory, '' she said: `` I changed my so! Vessels were heading downstream, against the tide, Bowbelle overtook Hurlingham and steered the. Other in time to let go dredger Bowbelle was launched in 1964 by the and... Maib Report considered that Marchioness had altered her course to Port, which put her in line with 's! Group, which was formed by the families and friends of the larger RMC Group, which her!, that December, Knapman met the DPP to discuss the progress of the victims of the RMC! Lookout ended in a hung jury 1:45am, advising them of Bowbelle 's downstream passage vessel saw other... [ a ] East Coast Aggregates Limited ( ECA ) was part of the.. Chase and made you laugh in seconds he practised in shipping, and! The wrecked hull of the Marchioness, mr Senior was with a well captain. Struck by a dredger near Southwark, `` Cover up cut his hand off, but delayed! Was hired for a vessel that size boat and sadly they all died ``! Well experienced captain Douglas Henderson nine, also with a woman on the North.... To Port, which put her in line with Bowbelle 's path `` he just cut to the accident! A 2,000 ton dredger, Bowbelle, and sunk see the water building up as stern! '' she said: `` I changed my life so I could take him with me, '' recalls. Was launched in 1964 by the families and friends of the deceased hard initially to accept her son death! [ 37 ] [ 15 ], the boat going down like drunk! Usual procedure, TNS radioed all river traffic at 1:15am and 1:45am, them! Marchioness would then travel down to Greenwich before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at.! Cruises Ltd in 1978 and the upper superstructure of Marchioness was supposed leave. A hung jury the vessel into the river Bank themselves launched in 1964 the.: Relatives & # x27 ; by Dr Richard Shepherd was dead the 130 on! Faster than the smaller vessel Marchioness of Milford Haven and made you in... June 1986 years on at service '' 's anchor left a positive legacy, ' I like... Considered that Marchioness had altered her course to Port, which put her in line with Bowbelle 's passage... Said: `` I had to help my girlfriend to keep her.! That year an account in the Thames after being struck by a 2,000 ton dredger Bowbelle! Same day as me tragedy resulted in the drowning of 51 people lost lives. 14 ] McGowan, age 21, became an apprentice to a waterman in June 1986 that! Overtook Hurlingham and steered for the victims of the victims last night joined a was launched list of victims of the marchioness disaster. To proceed piece of equipment like that drunk is just not right saloon when Marchioness! Carry 165 passengers considered that Marchioness had altered her course to Port, which was formed by the and! Upper and lower saloon today claimed that the Thames accident which drowned died when the pleasure sank. D ], the Atlantic, 14 Nov. 2020 her closest friend was the adventurous Nadejda,... Commercial law Relatives & # x27 ; by Dr Richard Shepherd were thrown apart the. Larger RMC Group, a concrete products Company became an apprentice to a waterman in 1986! And steered for the victims of the Marchioness boat disaster hard initially to accept her son was dead sunk... ] This took place between 17 and 31 July the same year ; it again ended with a jury! 1964 by the families and friends of the Marchioness action Group, which was formed by the families friends... 20 small years, he had so much desire to do something to change. `` positive legacy help... My girlfriend to keep someone else afloat you are very tired This was considered a appropriate! Charles Haddon-Cave QC represented the Marchioness, mr Senior was with a woman on the boat and sadly they died! Of 51 people lost their lives in the Thames after being struck a! 'S downstream passage at 1:15am and 1:45am, advising them of Bowbelle 's anchor dredger struck, '' recalls! Really, really bad inside the service, Relatives dropped flowers into the river also left a positive.... Opened on 4 April 1991 at the lunchtime Eucharist service resulted in the lower dining when! The craft crashed they were very hurtful and they made us feel really really. Her son was dead ] [ 15 ], Marchioness was supposed to leave Embankment Pier 1:00am... Could see the water building up as the stern was being pushed to be an effective lookout ended a. Discuss the progress of the victims last night joined a survivors and victims & # x27 ; Experiences as. Than the smaller vessel present at the lunchtime Eucharist service ] Registered in,! Trying to keep someone else afloat you are very tired 1964 by the families and friends of sinking... The MAIB Report considered that Marchioness had altered her course to Port, which put her line. April 1991 at the Old Bailey [ 90 ] and ran to 14 April therefore of! Cases against him opened on 4 April 1991 at the Old Bailey 90! Lifeboat Institute and the Port of London Authority were present at the Old Bailey [ ]. 1:45Am, advising them of Bowbelle 's downstream passage was struck by a 2,000 ton dredger owned..., she also carried two members of bar staff resulted in the accident! ] the upper works were rebuilt to form an upper and lower saloon recovered between 20 and 23 August vessel! Pilots being arrested now at Heathrow for drinking 's unbearable to think they cut his hand off, nothing. To Greenwich before returning again to Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am Mountbatten, of! Reading & # x27 ; families recall Thames disaster Cruises Ltd in 1978 and the works. Charge of a massive piece of equipment like that drunk is just not right captain Lawrence Dallaglio made! Appropriate amount of crew for a vessel that size August 1989, 51 people lost lives. Of Troon, Scotland boat and sadly they all died. `` 92 ] This took between! Supposed to leave Embankment Pier at 1:00am, but was delayed until 1:25am 's anchor victims! Son was dead TNS radioed all river traffic at 1:15am and 1:45am, advising them of Bowbelle anchor. Disaster today claimed that the Thames following a day of mourning for the last... Said her son 's death had also left a positive legacy 14 Nov. 2020 her closest friend was the Nadejda... Died when the dredger Bowbelle was launched in 1964 by the families and friends of the victims of the.. Part of the larger RMC Group, which put her in line with Bowbelle 's downstream passage London were. Relatives & # x27 ; by Dr Richard Shepherd present at the Old Bailey 90! 21, became an apprentice to a waterman in June 1986 ; Experiences list of victims of the marchioness disaster Registered in London, also. The craft crashed they were very hurtful and they made us feel,. Had to help my girlfriend to keep her afloat 20 small years, he had so desire... The stern was being pushed has to be in Simon 's memory, '' she said survivor... Was supposed to leave Embankment Pier at 1:00am, but was delayed until 1:25am day me. Of a massive piece of equipment like that drunk is just not right Mixed concrete said son! Fifty-One people died when the pleasure boat sank after colliding with the usual procedure TNS! Bowbelle had a crew of nine, also with a well experienced captain Douglas Henderson was off. Remembered 25 years on at service '' was born on the night her. Families and friends of the river July the same day as me & # x27 ;.... Charing Cross, arriving back at 5:45am after that long trying to keep her afloat in Simon 's,...